Choosing Between a WordPress Website and an AI Website Builder

by | Nov 16, 2026

Every business requires a website presence. The process to set up a website can be daunting if you haven’t been through it before. Even if you have, it’s likely it was years ago or potentially an experience you’d like to forget. To add to the long list of considerations, you now have platforms like Squarespace, WIX, and Lovable claiming their AI-powered builders can take away the stress and build it for you. Before you full-send an AI-powered website builder for your business’s website, think deeply about platform selection and its implications.

Start With Platform Selection

Armada Digital develops, hosts, and supports WordPress websites. I’ll share our reasons for this, but it doesn’t mean other options aren’t worth considering. The type, size, complexity of your business and the speed at which you need to create are all factors.

We opt for WordPress because of the level of both control and freedom it offers when building specifically for professional services and trades businesses. These businesses do not sell products online and often rely heavily on both local search and educational content in order to promote the business.

One of the biggest reasons WordPress is our platform of choice is our ability to structure the backend in a way that will scale with you. We can essentially create filterable folders for services, industries, blog posts, press pieces, or case studies—any content that will certainly expand over time. The CMS (content management system) side of things prevents the need to overhaul your site structure each time a new service line is added. Similarly, WordPress allows us extensive control over technical search engine optimization. In years past, we conducted our SEO Foundational deliverable on platforms outside of WordPress and always felt left wanting. While still effective, the ability to metaphorically dive into the weeds is where we’re able to maximize results for our clients.

If you build on a platform like Squarespace or WIX, you have a set backend user experience and are reliant on their support if there is an interface glitch. Whereas we’re able to build the WordPress backend in a way that normal, non-developers can make sense of, all while not locking you into working with us for life. With WordPress, we can confidently say that you, the client, own your website files, database, and all content. All of these elements can be exported and handed over to you. Because of the structure, we can create daily back-ups of your site files and easily reference or revert to a previous version of the site.

WordPress also offers an extensive network of third-party integrations to make tools talk. Our agency includes premium-level licenses to tools like Gravity Forms and Gravity Wiz, both of which can get real fancy. While there is rarely a need for us to build a custom integration, it is nice to have that as an option should the need arise.

Meanwhile, platforms like Squarespace, WIX, and Lovable are proprietary. There is no exporting your site structure, and you cannot shop different website hosts to reduce costs. There is a level of simplicity that is attractive when just starting out, but you may find yourself quickly frustrated with the lack of customization.

If WordPress Wins, Provider & Host Selection Come Next

If you were to ask AI about the pros/cons of opting for WordPress over Squarespace, much of the cons have to do with the level of maintenance required and the potential cost of having to pay for that maintenance and the level of customization I boasted as a pro above.

While thinking through and researching the cons, I found myself thinking “Yeah, working with an agency to build a WordPress site may be more of an expense upfront, but a lot of the other cons aren’t necessarily true if it’s set up correctly from the start…”

For example, our websites are hosted with WPEngine, where we’re an Agency Partner. We lease our servers from them because it comes with a number of perks; one being that all of our clients have “Smart Plug-in Manager” built in. You can liken it to the auto-update function for apps on an iPhone, except this has a built-in fail-safe in that it automatically reverts should something fail. WPEngine also offers a number of protections from a security standpoint, and speaking from experience, has solid customer service if something does happen to go wrong at the server level.

For those who want to outsource WordPress hosting to an agency where you can speak to a real person rather than deal with GoDaddy, Bluehost, or the like, our Hosting program is $40/month. For those who want to outsource hosting and also never want to see the backend of a website, no matter how well structured and user-friendly it is, may I present our Concierge Website Services (CWS) program. We’ve learned enough to know that whether Squarespace, WIX, Lovable, or WordPress, just because you know how to update your website doesn’t mean you will or that it’s something you should be personally handling.

What About AI-Generated Websites?

While WordPress remains the industry standard for content-heavy websites, tools like Lovable, GoDaddy Airo, and Bluehost’s AI Website Builder promise a full website that starts with a prompt and delivers in minutes. Like any AI tool, the output is only going to be as good as your input. Unless working directly in the marketing field, a business owner isn’t the one who presents the site structure or user flow that will best serve their audience or evaluate the user experience, design, content, and search engine optimization that it returns.

While I view AI-generated websites as a worthwhile approach for those who need to bring an idea to market in a matter of minutes, I otherwise feel that the final product should include plenty of human input and collaboration along the way. Whether that’s with an experienced agency that can guide strategy and build for the future in WordPress, or an experienced team prompting on Claude is up to you!

Featured Insights

Read expert marketing insights from our team and get actionable takeaways.

No results found.

Subscribe to receive proven tactics to scale your service-based business.

Join our monthly newsletter, where we share marketing insights and celebrate clients who are making big waves.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.